Introduction to Critical Values and Critical Regions
When we conduct a hypothesis test, we need a principled way to decide when our evidence is strong enough to reject the null hypothesis . This is where critical values and critical regions come in.
Critical Value: A critical value is a threshold value that marks the boundary of the critical region. It is determined by the chosen significance level and whether the test is one-tailed or two-tailed.
Critical Region: The critical region (also called the rejection region) is the set of values of the test statistic for which we reject . The total area of the critical region equals the significance level .
For a normal distribution, the standard critical z-values are:
| Test Type | Significance Level | Critical Value(s) |
|---|---|---|
| Two-tailed | 0.05 | |
| Two-tailed | 0.01 | |
| One-tailed (right) | 0.05 | |
| One-tailed (left) | 0.05 |
If the calculated test statistic falls inside the critical region (beyond the critical value), we reject . If it falls outside the critical region, we fail to reject . Notice the language , we never "accept" .
Choosing Between the z-Test and the t-Test
The most fundamental decision in a one-sample mean test is whether to use a z-test or a t-test. This depends entirely on whether the population standard deviation is known.
When is known , use the z-test:
The test statistic is:
Where is the sample mean, is the hypothesised population mean, is the known population standard deviation, and is the sample size. This statistic follows a standard normal distribution .
When is unknown , use the t-test:
The test statistic is:
Where is the sample standard deviation (used to estimate ). This statistic follows a t-distribution with degrees of freedom.
The decision rule is simple: known → z-test; unknown → t-test. This applies regardless of sample size. For large samples (), the t-distribution approximates the normal distribution closely, but you should still use the t-test if is unknown.
A very common mistake is choosing the test based on sample size alone. Sample size does not determine whether you use a z-test or t-test , knowledge of does.
Assumptions for the z-test:
- Population follows a normal distribution (or is large enough for the Central Limit Theorem to apply)
- is known
- Data points are independent
Assumptions for the t-test:
- Population follows a normal distribution (especially critical for small samples)
- is unknown
- Data points are independent