Question 1
A semi-log graph plots against (in years) for a population model . The best-fit line passes through the points and . What is the value of , the growth rate constant?No clue? Show me the answer
Correct answer
Correct!
IncorrectStep-by-step walkthrough
Choose a solution method
Method #1Approach 1Step 1: Identify the linearised form
Taking of gives . On a vs graph, the gradient equals directly.
Step 2: Calculate the gradient
Using points and :
Step 3: State the answer
Since the gradient of vs equals directly, we have .
Method #2Approach 2Step 1: Identify the key calculation needed
The gradient of the vs line equals . We need .
Step 2: Eliminate $m \approx 0.693$
. This would require , but the actual change is only . Eliminated.
Step 3: Eliminate $m \approx 0.462$
This would give , which does not match the observed change of . Eliminated.
Step 4: Eliminate $m \approx 0.154$
This gives . This might result from dividing by instead of . Eliminated.
Step 5: Confirm the correct answer
. The correct answer is .
Question 2
A log-log graph of against gives a straight line with gradient and -intercept . Which power law model correctly describes as a function of ?No clue? Show me the answer
Correct answer
Correct!
IncorrectStep-by-step walkthrough
Choose a solution method
Method #1Approach 1Step 1: Identify the log-log form
For , taking of both sides gives . The gradient is and the -intercept is .
Step 2: Read off parameters
Gradient and -intercept .
Step 3: Recover $a$
Since , we get . The model is .
Method #2Approach 2Step 1: Identify the structure needed
On a log-log graph, a straight line with gradient and intercept gives and .
Step 2: Eliminate $F = 4.8 \cdot r^{-2}$
This treats the -intercept as the value of directly, forgetting to apply the inverse . Since , . Eliminated.
Step 3: Eliminate $F = 10^{-2} \cdot r^{4.8}$
This swaps the roles of gradient and intercept, using the intercept as the exponent and the gradient as the base of . Eliminated.
Step 4: Eliminate $F = e^{4.8} \cdot r^{-2}$
Using is only appropriate when the -intercept is , i.e., on a semi-log graph. Here we have , so . Eliminated.
Step 5: Confirm the answer
The correct model is .